BioFuel Bad IDEA!!! One tank of Biofuel could feed a family for a year!

topic posted Mon, May 19, 2008 - 6:25 PM by  Inner
Share/Save/Bookmark
Advertisement
Did you know that one tank............... yes........... one tank of bio fuel is enough grain to feed a entire family for a year!
BioFuel is a joke and not the answer! Growing our energy , now the world doesn't have enough food to eat. One problem to the next.
Lets get it right!
posted by:
Inner
Canada
Advertisement
Advertisement
  • Another person falls for the "paint all possible biofuels with the corn ethanol brush" propaganda. I have just invented a machine into which you stick a dozen school lunches in one end and out the other comes a tank of gasoline! And we keep staving chidren active cleaning your windshield.

    There are people planting Jatropha curcas trees with the potential of being a source of both biodiesel and ethanol. They will be cultivated in such a way to change the worn out waste land where they are grown, into fertile food producing land when biofuels are no longer necessary. Start learning of the biofuel potential not running it down. A little of the rise in food prices come from unwise biofuel choices, but much of it is due to rising petroleum costs and the dropping dollar value.
  • yes, one tank of bio-d could feed one over weight fat ass family that cant stop eating only sugar and starch!
    Its really funny to me that people associate corn with food!! What the hell is corn??? Sugar and starch!!! stop eating the shit gaining a bunch of weight and driving your fattass around!!!
    • 1st we have free energy sources out their that actually produce more energy than is put into them ethanol is NOT one of them in any form.

      Food for Energy BAd idea.
      The problem is that we are replacing wheat and other grain producing crops are now being replaced by ethanol crops with by the way are genetically modified to hell and require tons of pesticides.

      No Growing Energy is not the solution it only depletes the soil more.

      Secondly I have the right to my opinion and do not apreciate the unwarranted and childish comments on the topic that is suppose to be for mature adults who want to have an intelligent conversation not children who want to make asses of themselves because they have nothing better to say than rude remarks.

      Once everyone is smart enough to have a real conversation feel free to join in but do stay on topic please.

      We are here to talk not put each other down.
      • Lets talk about unwarranted and childish and I quote "BioFuel is a joke and not the answer! Growing our energy , now the world doesn't have enough food to eat. One problem to the next. Lets get it right!" Maybe I'm stupid, but this to me is an inflammatory statement backed by emotion but little else. These kinds of statements are historically called trollling en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Internet_troll I'll leave it to you to follow up on the definition if you have any questions.

        In case you hadn't noticed this is the "Biodiesel Tribe" not the Ethanol Tribe, you probably didnt notice all that well that the topics here are "Proponents, activists, and other adherents of the many practical and other benefits of biodiesel." again the mention of biodiesel. So if you want to talk about the matter of being on topic you could start there.

        Secondly you are rehashing a conversation that has been IMHO been beaten to death here and also long before the media picked the story and well before you hopped in with your off topic comments on ethanol.

        Thirdly planting anything in the soil depletes it. Thats why crop rotation and fertilizing methodology are not only common practice but government mandate. Reference "The Dust Bowl" en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Dust_Bowl I'll leave it to you to follow up on that as well.

        Fourthly the whole push for alternative bio-energy thing is *SOLELY* and I MEAN SOLELY the result of the Corporate Farm Lobby who has single handedly managed to push the price of food commodities through the roof because the oversight for alternative energy is outlined by policies that the Bush Administration setup. Policies that encourage relief and subsidy for corporations and farmers that dont need it and does not encourage the development of non-food commodity based fuel sources. Ethanol can easily be produced as a byproduct from a variety of other sources and yet its not. Profit over all else, which has proven to be the Bush Administration Legacy.

        Biodiesel on the other hand by most of the users ON THIS TRIBE is produced by people who are RECYCLING WASTE VEGGIE OIL. I'm pretty sure there isnt a single farmer here growing food crops and pressing them for oil.

        Finally I do not feel that your ethanol discussion is on topic for here. To expand on that I feel that gasoline engines are not only inferior in technology but also not efficient enough to even waste alternative fuel resources on. Ethanol is already a net loss of 10% by volume over gasoline when comparing efficiency, when you compound that with the fact the a gasoline engine is 10-30% less efficient than a diesel and your looking at a technology that even when its clean(er) burning is at a net loss in actual energy produced by up to 40% . Why bother putting ethanol fuel even into a hybrid that gets worse gas mileage than a VW TDI from 5 years ago?

        So I'm not going to pat you on the back for bringing up an old topic, or coming here with incomplete facts and inflammatory statements fueled by emotions... and I can only imagine what television show you are citing for your information/reference... I haven't yet begun to get stupid on you and I'd prefer to stick to the facts instead of judging your level of maturity or getting into another atypical flame war. But I will be happy to oblige you if you continue to attempt to lob insults.

        So now since you've brought up your off topic inflammatory comment, lets hear you formulate an intelligent opinion (on ethanol production) to defend yourself.
        • While I couldn't agree with you more on most points, the government emphasis on crop rotation and the govt subsidies of fallow fields pretty much ended with a stroke of Earl Butz's pen way back during the Carter administration. While some renewed govt attention may exist these days towards sustainable farming practices, it's nowhere near enough, nor anywhere near what it once was. Those former policies (interestingly enough) were driven by a perceived need to stabilize crop (mostly grain) PRICES, not necessarily to support wise farming practices. But the net result served both purposes well. Now we have a volatile grain market and planting of every available square foot of land, including some very marginal areas which will produce low yields at the expense of neighboring wildlands. Bad news.

          But the good news is that the farm bill which just passed by veto override is likely the last of it's kind. Look for some very serious evolution in the next four years leading up to the crafting of the subsequent farm bill.

          While ethanol really is beside the point for the purposes of this tribe, I do wonder if anyone is knowledgeable about the primary sources of methanol in this country, which does have some bearing ont he production of biodiesel. Do I remember correctly reading that huge quantities are imported?

          Now if we could just get rid of the "Blenders Credit" idiocy... Talk about the road to hell being paved with good intentions... maaaan.
          • Frankly Bio Fuel wont work in the long run for the big picture. Obviously not. We need a long term solution not a band aid. Jump on another eco train going no where fast. My biggest problem with bio fuels is how genetically modified oh and the fact that they are taking food out of people mouths, Are there any organic bio fuels? Anyone heard of it?
            • >Frankly Bio Fuel wont work in the long run for the big picture. Obviously not. We need a long term solution not a band aid. Jump on another eco train going no where fast. My biggest problem with bio fuels is how genetically modified oh and the fact that they are taking food out of people mouths, Are there any organic bio fuels? Anyone heard of it?

              This tribe is about biodiesel. Please contribute something about biodiesel or shut the hell up. There are plenty of other tribes where you can spew nonsense about whatever environmental issue of the moment you want to be passionate about.

              How genetically modfied what? I saw some hippie-shit last week about some completely organic non-GMO bio-fuel. Here's a hint:

              Pesticides increase crop yields, GMO increases crop yields. The greater the yield, the more people get fed..
              • >Pesticides increase crop yields, GMO increases crop yields. The greater the yield, the more people get fed..

                hmm, guess we wont see you heath on any of the organic tribes :)
                like you said, a completely different argument, better left for another forum.
                • Yup, it's doubtful that you'd see me on any of the organic tribes. It's just not something I'm that passionate about. I buy and eat organic food sometimes, but I consider myself fortunate that I live in an area of abundance where that's possible.

                  My point is that there are no silver bullets and there are no demons. Organic food is not a silver bullet, biodiesel is not a silver bullet, GMO-food isn't a demon and pesticides aren't a demon.
            • if i must dignify your answer (and why i bother, i'm not sure, since you obvsiouly don't read people's response to your passionate yet-uninformed posts), no, bio fuel are not a band aid. and no, they aren't here to replace regular gasoline/diesel.

              in the future, with good energy planning, we will have multiple sources of energy )such as solar, hydro, and bio fuels) all working together to ensure that mankind isn't stuck in the same place we are now - relying on one type of fuel.

              as uninformed as your posts are, i think we all agree with one thing - virgin bio fuel made from corn is a bad, bad idea brought about by the US government subsidies and the corn/soy industries. NO ONE here wants rain forests cut to make room for corn-based ethanol. NO ONE.

              so, let's re-cap:
              if you do sustainable farming, and make sure the ground is NOT depleted because you rotate crops, you don't deplete the soil, you actually can re-invigorate it.

              if you use waste vegi-oil to make your bio-diesel (again, this IS the bio DIESEL tribe), you are helping reduce the amount of oil going into landfills, and using a fuel that burns MUCH cleaner than diesel, gasoline, or even ethanol.

              but, i'm wasting my typing fingers here :)
      • waste.....vegetable........oil

        WASTE

        vegetable

        oil

        do you understand that restaurants have to pay companies to dispose of their waste oils
        that we bio freaks come along and collect for them
        to save them money

        and give us bio fuel
        we're not only saving the environment, but also our pocketbooks and their pocketbooks, without having to "grow our energy" as you put it


        WASTE
        VEGETABLE
        OIL

        got it?

        good
  • Brittany,
    Not like you're ever going to chime back into this discussion or even read this, (because you've obviously bitten off more than you can chew with this one)... but this biting of my tongue has left me dissatisfied.

    You should tell the Wright Bro's that their stupid airplane idea is ridiculous and since the 1st draft was a bit wonky, they should shelf the whole concept of air travel.

    Ever hear of Algae? Well, there are many oil moguls trying to corner the market and develop Algae-based (vegetable oil) Biodiesel... it's a race for who can trademark the technology first.

    The potential for (and benefits of) algae biofuels is endless and doesn't overlap food markets... doesn't use wasteful irrigation, soil, expensive and diesel-guzzling equipment to produce etc...

    If everyone squashed ideas as soon as Rev A was released, we'd be living in the dark ages still.

    Have a little faith in human ingenuity and the ability to perfect, simplify and refine processes that ALWAYS, ALWAYS start off looking a bit rough.

    I agree that using virgin oil from soil-based feedstocks is a wasteful bucket under a mega-leak.. so I validate your passion on that side of things.. but that's not what "biofuels" are all about... and that's not what we here at this group would probably consider a long-term solution to the global energy crisis.

Recent topics in "Biodiesel"

Topic Author Replies Last Post
Algae: The Biofuel Revolution Rocky 3 November 28, 2009
dodge sprinter VIDA 21 August 29, 2009
FREE JET FUEL! Runs Great in diesel cars. Mike 21 April 14, 2009
Pickens Plan Action Alert Rocky 3 March 21, 2009